260 replies to this topic

[lion]

Im gonna make players highscores with 50 best players.

[doctorfunk]

that's a good idea thanks

[krazzerous]

I think you should just use the randomizer Xillax used for the Team cup. That way, teams don't get any easy ways.

[Slizer]

Why should we have the 4 top clans in the same group and 4 top noobs in 1 group, so the final will be 1 pro clan vs 1 noob clan. It's supposed to be easy for the top clans in group stages, the deeper they go into the tournament, the harder it will get, group matches will be easy if they're a top clan, quarterfinals harder, semifinal harder, final harder (cause you simply meet a better clan the further you go in the cup).

[krazzerous]

Why should we have the 4 top clans in the same group and 4 top noobs in 1 group, so the final will be 1 pro clan vs 1 noob clan. It's supposed to be easy for the top clans in group stages, the deeper they go into the tournament, the harder it will get, group matches will be easy if they're a top clan, quarterfinals harder, semifinal harder, final harder (cause you simply meet a better clan the further you go in the cup).

For all you know, one of these "noob" clans can easily take you out. For example, you putting sL in the bottom of the list, when they've clearly proven they can hang with the better clans. You're basing the "skills" on your own personal judgement. Clearly I don't think its fair. The only fair way about it, would be to make it random. This isn't like sports, where you play all year long and get the best record and be able to play against the worst team in your first round.

Edited by krazzerous, 11 March 2010 - 03:04 PM.

[Slizer]

For all you know, one of these "noob" clans can easily take you out. For example, you putting sL in the bottom of the list, when they've clearly proven they can hang with the better clans. You're basing the "skills" on your own personal judgement. Clearly I don't think its fair. The only fair way about it, would be to make it random. This isn't like sports, where you play all year long and get the best record and be able to play against the worst team in your first round.

Basing the skills on my own personal judgment? I haven't judged or ranked any clan for this cup, this is Doc's job. And I wouldn't have underestimated sL for that matter like putting them on the bottom. I have no problem with a random mix-up in the very first FairPlay v1.00 Cup, in the next cup we can easily rank the clans based on how well they played in the last cup by analyzing the points and score differences. But it would've been bad and likely boring if 4 top clans would end up in the same group.

Edited by Slizer, 11 March 2010 - 03:20 PM.

[Junior]

I think you should just use the randomizer Xillax used for the Team cup. That way, teams don't get any easy ways.

xillax used seeds krazzy lol so ye idd they should use the same system as xillax.
edit: oh and ur rankin slizer for a next cup will be hard since full is filled with hoppers and every 2 days u got a new clans filled with some more hoppers

Edited by Junior, 11 March 2010 - 03:44 PM.

[Slizer]

xillax used seeds krazzy lol so ye idd they should use the same system as xillax.
edit: oh and ur rankin slizer for a next cup will be hard since full is filled with hoppers and every 2 days u got a new clans filled with some more hoppers

So what? It doesn't matter, then we have a reason for the ranking.

[Bone20]

Visit www.random.org tbh heldro that sucks i prefer est sl bps

Edited by Bone20, 11 March 2010 - 06:31 PM.

[krazzerous]

Are they allowed to switch members during the match? I don't think I saw a rule about that, I could be blind though lol

[Luigiz]

Are they allowed to switch members during the match? I don't think I saw a rule about that, I could be blind though lol

yes they are allowed to sub

[doctorfunk]

ye they are, but I think subs should be allowed in case of emergency
or @half
or you think they should be done at any moment?

[krazzerous]

ye they are, but I think subs should be allowed in case of emergency
or @half
or you think they should be done at any moment?

In wars they usually do it once the player they want to sub dies I think.

[doctorfunk]

seems okay then

[krazzerous]

seems okay then

Make sure you add the rule before some people start to rage about switching members during the match lol.

[Slizer]

Ye, changing sub is allowed anytime when the player is dead. No pause is needed, just unlock and !gr.

[bing bang blaow]

i dont think its a good idea to allow subs during match. only if one has technical(or other) issues or between the 2 sides..

[kays]

Yeah but if a player has some sucky moment, I dont think it'd be fair not to let his team sub him. After all, as long as they don't disturb the match, dnt think there's any prob..

[Slizer]

He can just sub when he's dead, it takes like 5 seconds...

[Brighty]

yea indeed, and i guess the player wich has a bad day at that moment don't want to let his team down by
playing bassicly a '3 v 4' on that moment ( or 4v5 )

and teams/clans can also make tactial subs for several reasons, so i think it should be allowed.

BUT let the ref/admin know you are about to sub to avoid whining situations.