100 replies to this topic

[abu]

shut up zioni u lost 10-1

[malign]

It's completely irrelevant, Snugg. I see no relevance in a 1v1 with 5v5, only that it's the same game played. It's in my opinion completely unnecessary. It's not logical at all to end a match like that, to prove the best in a 5v5 match you'll just have to play 5v5 till end. till 5 rounds after that. I don't see why people wouldn't play this, 'tired' / no focus? Cry some more.

[abu]

i dont like this idea just keep this 2x5/ 2x10 maybe it shouldnt be the same day but its the best way to know whos the best

[doctorfunk]

Team cup;

avelgem vs nsz 13-13
line-ups

avelgem
Butcher, Muse, Snugg, Fastcolt and a 5th.. Koffee or smth whoever is in avelgem

nsz
Cheap, Prez, Renzo, Defqon, Joey

gj im not in the lineup, teamless from now on.

[Nasta]

x2

[malign]

But it's not real, dokterfunk. Look butcher is banned and he's in the line-up!

BTW, Snugg's suggestion is UNNEEDED. 2x5!!!!!

Edited by malign, 19 July 2010 - 01:54 PM.

[P4P3R]

gj im not in the lineup, teamless from now on.

Noob I didn't put you in because otherwise my example wouldn't be right.. seeing as you would own them all at once even if it was 1on1.

[snugg]

just your opinion malign! Let cupadmins decide. If they want something fresh, fairer, exciting and something that tests all aspects of a team in case of a tie, not just the teamwork but also the players in it, then they will choose snugg's 1on1 as a method to decide.

@Joey: maybe instead of using it in important cupwars, we can use it as an extension for ordinary clanwars if both sides agree to use it.

[Rait]

no, arc 1vs1 is uber booring - better camper/glitcher wins.

I agree, we have dealt with the rematches fine, just re-arrange the new match and we're done.

[P4P3R]

@Joey: maybe instead of using it in important cupwars, we can use it as an extension for ordinary clanwars if both sides agree to use it.

I don't see why not.. would be a good way of trying this method.

[snugg]

yea and if its generally accepted we can use it for cupwar ties then. We have a deal!

[doctorfunk]

I agree that my idea sounds most fair and less boring than regular war right after.

[azzy]

Who's going to play this after a draw in a normal clanwar? I'm usually pissed and already RQ then

[HowLinMaD]

Well if a cupwar ends in 15-15, isn't it kinda obvious that teamwork of both sides is equal. Therefore, this method relies more on the individual differences in two clans to decide who wins. Let's just give this method a name like Snugg's Penalties or something and make it available to future cupadmins. They will have to choose between the regular extension war or Snugg's Penalties as a decision rule in knockout stages.

Why this is fail:

Some teams are formed with players who are not 1on1 players. Meaning every clan doesn't own 5 good all-around players. That's why each player has a specific spot during a clan war.
This would just show who's better 1on1 skillwise which quite frankly shows shit about their 5on5 skills.
Fact is that this will give a clear advantage to clans who base their gameplay on glitching/whoring/being lame overall. And clans with ACTUAL teamwork will lose.

Shitty idea, imho.

A rematch just shows which clan can hold the grip longer and is better overall.
Looking how |she| got raped in their rematch i'd say that sK. won pretty fair and square.
While some 1on1 glitch/luck/faggotry system would maybe have granted |she| the win (though i doubt as their only solid 1on1 player was Zioni that match imho).



And yea i repeat.
This system sounds gay.

What next? Maybe lets decide the winner with a fucking RPG war? Knives main? Noscopes on roof? FUck this.

[P4P3R]

I agree that my idea sounds most fair and less boring than regular war right after.

How is yours most fair.. side (dis)advantages are massive here?

[Radical]

Interesting that after 4 pages no one mentioned this flaw:

you can sit behind a corner and your team will use the third view to tell you when to pop up with shotgun and win.

[Mr. Mike]

u can do that in war also.

[Radical]

u can do that in war also.

True, but in a war the circumstances are never the same from round to round(health issues, time issues, ammo issues, the case could be far away in a bad spot, etc).

Edited by Radical, 19 July 2010 - 02:42 PM.