57 replies to this topic

[katana.]

I wouldn't consider 3v playing c4's pretty random line-up a final.

I don't really care though. Was just coming up with ideas how to make it more interesting (more matches-> better cup imo).

Whats the point in groups then if you let 80% advance just to play 1 more match? overkill
But yes it was a final tbh if you look at certain things! but lets not dwell on that here

Edited by ShaoliN, 17 January 2011 - 12:35 PM.

[Juul]

maybe final 3? and then K.O.? just an idea but whatever works guys!

can we still add players to our line-ups?

[Movsk.]

Nomatch s played yet, ofc you can add

Edited by Movsk., 17 January 2011 - 12:43 PM.

[charles (sika)]

I'm not sure adding all these extra matches is a good idea. Getting everyone to play their matches is hard enough as it is.

[- RAUL -]

True Sikasu

[doctorfunk]

Whats the point in groups then if you let 80% advance just to play 1 more match? overkill
But yes it was a final tbh if you look at certain things! but lets not dwell on that here

1st team of A would play with 4th of B, so ye there's a reason to get no1 seed.
besides like Howlin said from groups to semis is kinda bad.

[FrozenTsunami]

I agree with howlin & doc, but that's what happens on a nearly 10 year old demo, there' s just not enough teams to expand the cup..
Going from 10 teams to 8 is kinda lame imo, but whatever you guys want..

[l'ANGELINOOO `]

4 advance and then into quarters with KO would be better.

Going straight into semis after group phase would kinda suck.

Especially if the top 3 teams are all in 1 group y0!

i meant 3teams PER group, gives you 6.

or 4 per group, gives u 8 over, but that would take too long.

[Juul]

ya, first 3 go throug, im pretty keen with that

[katana.]

1st team of A would play with 4th of B, so ye there's a reason to get no1 seed.
besides like Howlin said from groups to semis is kinda bad.

no its not, you get 4 chances to be in a overall top 4 out of 10, yo uget plenty of chances and games to qualify
what hes saying is you need to be in a overall top 8 out of 10 lol..and the only ''plus'' side is you get to play 1 more match, overkill on groups
top 3 can work too tho but id still go with top 2 just so we dont stretch cups more then needed

[Junior]

i meant 3teams PER group, gives you 6.

or 4 per group, gives u 8 over, but that would take too long.

ur wrong, ur system of 3 teams advancing per group would mean the cup lasts longer lol

[doctorfunk]

no its not, you get 4 chances to be in a overall top 4 out of 10, yo uget plenty of chances and games to qualify
what hes saying is you need to be in a overall top 8 out of 10 lol..and the only ''plus'' side is you get to play 1 more match, overkill on groups
top 3 can work too tho but id still go with top 2 just so we dont stretch cups more then needed

yea but it's one more week and 4 additional team get to play a match and 4team play an extra game. So 8 teams see extra action, also group phase wouldn't be so tight and you wouldn't postpone the game because you miss your 5th best player and maybe even it would speed things up because of that. ANyway what's wrong with you? You don't like cupwars or what?

[l'ANGELINOOO `]

ur wrong, ur system of 3 teams advancing per group would mean the cup lasts longer lol

????

[doctorfunk]

becoz it would angel it wopuld be 2weeks longer than the version without quarters and 1week longer than the quarters.

[Junior]

????

groupstage = 4 matches for each clan

KO with 4 going through in each group = 3 more matches

ur system with 3 advancing would mean 2 more groups of 3 or 1 big group of 6

after the groups of 3 semis would mean 4 matches, final would mean 3 more matches (which would be the same as KO with 8 teams)

big group of 6 would be 5 more matches.
so either way ur system would never make the cup any shorter than the original system

[katana.]

yea but it's one more week and 4 additional team get to play a match and 4team play an extra game. So 8 teams see extra action, also group phase wouldn't be so tight and you wouldn't postpone the game because you miss your 5th best player and maybe even it would speed things up because of that. ANyway what's wrong with you? You don't like cupwars or what?

lol its because i like cupwars im proposing it, i want teams to give everything during the groups, not be like oh we won 2 games we made it whohoo ;s we got that enough in normal cw's, cupwars should be non stop top of the line games!

[HowLinMaD]

lol its because i like cupwars im proposing it, i want teams to give everything during the groups, not be like oh we won 2 games we made it whohoo ;s we got that enough in normal cw's, cupwars should be non stop top of the line games!

I'd say the group phase is sort of a warm-up anyway lol.

Ideally having 10 teams would be better yea but going straight into semis is kinda gay still i think.

And you still have something to fight for, the one who gets most points in the group phase gets an easier way to finals really.

[l'ANGELINOOO `]

groupstage = 4 matches for each clan

KO with 4 going through in each group = 3 more matches

ur system with 3 advancing would mean 2 more groups of 3 or 1 big group of 6

after the groups of 3 semis would mean 4 matches, final would mean 3 more matches (which would be the same as KO with 8 teams)

big group of 6 would be 5 more matches.
so either way ur system would never make the cup any shorter than the original system

you are absolutly right, BUT where on earth did I mention to make the cup shorter? =D

I was more like thinking that going straight into semi's would might make it too short, could be wrong tho since you gotta play 4 matches first.

I'd say the group phase is sort of a warm-up anyway lol.

Ideally having 10 teams would be better yea but going straight into semis is kinda gay still i think.

And you still have something to fight for, the one who gets most points in the group phase gets an easier way to finals really.

Cant deny my agreement here.

But letting 4 clans PER Group through is also a bit too much. So'd let 3 clans PER group too.

6 over > re schedule it into 2 groups of 3 > 2 PER GROUP goes through Semis > final

[Junior]

i meant 3teams PER group, gives you 6.

or 4 per group, gives u 8 over, but that would take too long.

you are absolutly right, BUT where on earth did I mention to make the cup shorter? =D

I was more like thinking that going straight into semi's would might make it too short, could be wrong tho since you gotta play 4 matches first.

nab

[l'ANGELINOOO `]

nab

the fuck jr, u rly can't read or something?

that still doesn't show i wanna make the cup shorter, just NOT TOO LONG.
but atleast a bit longer than 2 per group that advance straight into semi's